Learning to Live Again

by smp4ever

BONG! BONG! BONG! The grandfather clock struck 3! How many more sleepless nights or nights of thrashing about in bed could I endure? I was tired of waking up on sweat drenched sheets. The circles under my eyes were getting deeper and darker. Drinking, crying, riding Cooch, talking to Pa…nothing seemed to help. When and how would peace come to me? I was losing my battle with finding reasons to live.

I had to get away. I needed to get away, away from the memories, away from so much loss, pain, and sadness that surrounded me here. The concerned look on my father’s face was becoming a constant. Leaving would be hard on Pa but I knew he’d understand. Heck, he was the one who kept suggesting I take an extended vacation. He saw how I had thrown myself into my work and said I earned time off. Finally, I made up my mind. I’d pack my bags and be on my way tomorrow morning.

Standing by the front door, Pa and I looked deeply into each other’s eyes. Both of us understood the depth of love we had for one another just in that single look. The tears welled up in our eyes. Then Pa grabbed me and wrapped his strong arms around me. It was in those arms that I had always found my comfort and my safe place. The child within wished I could stay there forever inhaling Pa’s Bay Rum aftershave and aromatic pipe tobacco.  We slowly broke our embrace, sniffed, and wiped away our tears. After giving each other a half- hearted smile, I picked up my bags.

“Make sure you keep in touch and let us know how you’re doing,” Pa said.

“I don’t know where this journey will take me. I just know I have to get away.”

“I know, Son. You don’t have to explain.”

“You’ll hear from me, Pa. I promise. 

I’m not taking the buckboard after all. It’s just going to be me and Cochise. I’ll unpack the suitcases in the barn and shove what I need in my saddlebags.”

“Ok, Son. I’ll take care of the suitcases later.”

“Thanks, Pa, and you take care of yourself!”

 I turned and headed out the door. Pa didn’t follow. He knew better. Besides strong arms, Pa had the greatest inner strength of anyone I’d ever known. 

I’m sure Pa was praying for me inside that door. I hoped God would hear his prayers.

After riding since sunup this morning, I stopped. The sound of a gentle flowing stream beckoned me, and I knew it was a good place to set up camp. Boy, was I tired and sore from being in the saddle far too many hours. I stripped down and meandered over to the stream with Cooch. While he drank his fill, I jumped into the water to wash off hours of dust and dirt. The stream was very cold as my male organ discovered, but refreshing. It gave me sufficient vigor to get my campfire going and to make coffee. I only had enough energy left to eat a little beef jerky and hardtack. After stoking the fire to make sure uninvited four legged guests stayed away, I settled down on my blanket with my saddle under my head. I looked up into the night sky; my eyes fixed on the twinkling lights. It was mesmerizing! Each star seemed to wink at me. One star in particular appeared so bright! I swore I could hear Hoss’s voice. 

“Hey, Joe. What’s happened to my adventurous, daredevil little brother? You got us into more trouble with your harebrained schemes. Should I remind you of the time you decided to be Joe Cartwright, Detective? I snapped the reins when you yelled at me to follow the would-be bank robbers. Next thing I knew I was flying through the air and landed on my belly on the ground. The horses weren’t hooked up to the wagon! You also had me put my ear against the wrong door. A six turned upside down is a 9!  Remember? Thanks to your little blunder, I got punched in the nose by a woman bigger than me!

How about another time when Pa made you the boss? You forced me to help you rob the bank. Pa almost had to sell the Ponderosa to get out of that fix. I won’t even bring up the matter of the mules! 

In both those madcap adventures, Pa pressed charges and had us jailed. I recall that I got most of the bruises,too! 

Gosh, we did have fun though, plus in the end, we saved the day! 

Joe, it’s time for you to get that spunk back! You can do it, Little Brother! Get on with living!”

Another twinkling star winked at me. The words sounded so sweet and were injected with a light-heartedness.

“Hello, My Mud Pie Eater!” 

“Laura?”  

“Taking a plunge into the pond when you tried to get the snow star flower for me was so Joe Cartwright. You acted without concern for your own well being. All you wanted to do was please me and make me happy. Building a fire in the cabin and getting a blanket to put around my rain soaked body was part of your charm and sweetness. However, I did have to ask you to turn around while I removed my dress. 

Get that impulsive, throw caution to the wind, caring, and sweet Joe back. You can do it, My Darling!” 

Another and another and another star burned extra brightly. Each one winked at me in its own extraordinary way.  I knew who these three stars were. Julia, Amy, and Sally were special women in my life to whom I had given my heart. 

“You were so young and had an indomitable spirit. When you walked into Julia’s Palace and came to my aid, I knew I wouldn’t be able to resist you. You awakened a sensation inside of me that I thought had died. Even though I tried to push you away, my heart belonged to you.”

Next, Amy’s voice could be heard. 

“Oh Joe, you were my first love. I recited Shakespeare to you, but your words, to my ears, were much more eloquent. Your lips were so soft and tender. I was ready to run away with you and marry. I know I said it could never be, a Cartwright and a Bishop, but my heart told me differently.”

“My dear Joe,” Sally said. “When you came into the bank and told me about the ring, my heart skipped a beat. That news made me so excited, the same way you always made me feel. I remember how my knees buckled the first time you kissed me on the lips. No one had ever had an effect on me like you. Also, Daddy loved the thought of you being his son-in-law. I hope my Bible, which my father gave you, is bringing you comfort.”

In unison my three angels reminded me that I made them feel alive and loved. 

Amy and Julia were so grateful. 

“You came to our defense and risked your own life trying to protect us!”

“For me, Joe, you got justice.” Sally said. “You pursued Horace until he admitted his guilt.”

“What a hero you were to all of us! We know you will always carry us in your heart. Loving you and you loving us filled our lives with so much happiness. You need to take our love and let it fill you with joy again. We believe in you, Joe! Now, get back into the game of life! We’re watching over you!”

This star is different. It’s the first star I ever remember. 

“Mama?” 

“Oui, Mon Petit Amour. You were so active inside me. Your little feet kicked me constantly and probably bruised my insides! After you were born, you were like a locomotive, constantly in motion! Papa and I could never keep up with our laughing, mischievous, happy, little boy. A true, free-spirited toddler, you loved to run around naked. Papa would have to scoop you up when you’d try to escape out the front door. He’d blow raspberries on your belly and then deposit my giggling, little boy back into my arms so I could get you dressed. You were a handful! The poor chickens were terrorized by you chasing after them and trying to grab them. When Papa and I would take you riding on our horses, you were fearless. Your little voice would yell, “Faster, faster!” Loving life was how we described you.

Mon Petit, find that rambunctious, exuberant little boy in you, and get that fire burning again!” 

One last twinkling star winked at me. I knew it was Alice. 

“Your smile melted my heart. Oh Joe, what little time we had together as husband and wife brought me more happiness and satisfaction than I had ever known. We couldn’t keep our hands off each other! Being late for dinner at your Pa’s house several times wasn’t only my fault! You were a very willing participant! Joe, your capacity to love is so great. Your little baby boy and I want you to stop wasting time. Remember Joe, even one day wasted is one less day of living. Live for all of us. Make us proud.

Forever!”

Joe woke up with a start!

 Was that a dream? 

Either way, it didn’t matter. For the first time in a long time, Joe felt very different from the way he had been feeling. He couldn’t explain it. He just knew it was time to get back among the living. 

His first stop brought him to Folsom, a town outside of Sacramento. A circus had come to perform. Joe got settled at the hotel. Remembering the promise he made to his father, he went to the telegraph office to send a telegram letting Pa know he was okay. Then he strolled over to where the trapeze artists were practicing their acrobatic acts. Joe enjoyed watching them fly through the air. Suddenly, one of the trapezists slipped! Thankfully, he fell into the netting, but unfortunately, he banged his wrist on the pole. Joe could hear the crack and ran over to see if he could help. 

“Is there something I can do?”  

A voice from behind Joe yelled, “Yes Sir. Put on these fleshings and take Omar’s place.” 

“What? Omar? You mean the guy who just fell? Are you kidding me? Oh no, not me!”

 “Young Man, I’m not kidding. Didn’t you just ask if you could help? You look strong and very athletic. I can tell you’re very agile, too!” 

“Yes, but, but… me… up there? I didn’t mean that type of help!”

“Don’t worry! Nothing fancy. We’ll show you what you have to do!”

 “And what the heck are fleshings?” Joe asked. 

“It’s this tight, skin colored clothing. Now hurry and change! There’s no time to waste!” 

Joe’s heart started racing and he could feel the redness from blushing creeping up to his cheeks and forehead. Sweat was dripping down his back and Joe could feel his armpits begin to perspire. Just the thought of being that far off the ground sent shivers up Joe’s spine!

“Listen Mister. I’m really sorry. I just don’t think I can do this!” 

Joe turned and began to walk away, but something made him stop. Was it the voices he had heard? Perhaps this was the opportunity he needed to start living again. Joe laughed to himself and thought, or die falling! He turned back to the man and hesitantly took the clothing from him. A few minutes later, Joe appeared in the fleshings. Wow, am I packed inside these tights! There’s not much left to the imagination! If only Pa could see me now! Second thought, not a good idea!

“Here I am!” Joe said to the trainer.

The man told Joe to start out by swinging back and forth on the trapeze. Joe grabbed the fly bar, closed his eyes, said a silent prayer, and jumped off the high pedestal board. Joe was flying through the air!  As he did, his confidence increased. This is exhilarating! Joe took to it like a bee to honey. The trainer knew Joe’s upper body strength would support the daring maneuvers he was about to introduce. Joe was ready! Adrenaline was pumping and his aerial act moved to another level. Joe completed a flip and also did a split! His only concern was that his tights didn’t split, too! 

It was time for his first performance. After getting over the embarrassment in his fleshings, Joe pushed his shoulders back and strutted his stuff over to the ladder. He shimmied up and planted his feet firmly on the platform. Joe took a deep breath and leaped off the board! Letting go had significant meaning for Joe. His momentum accelerated. Joe was flying forward and made the connection to the other side. The muscles in his arms and shoulders enabled him to control his movements with such grace and finesse.  He was having the time of his life! Success! Joe performed nightly to the whooping and hollering of men, women, and children.  He certainly had a lot to be proud of, in more ways than one! 

After a few weeks, Omar had healed, so Joe told his new friends it was time for him to move on. They hated to see Joe go. The carnival family had really grown to love him. Also, crowds were the largest the circus had ever had. Perhaps, one reason was because no one filled out fleshings like Joe did! 

After looking at his map, Joe decided to head south. He journeyed to Rosarito Beach, a little south of Tijuana. There was only one hotel in town so Joe checked in and got settled. The room was clean and comfortable and that’s what Joe needed to be. He went to the bathhouse, peeled off his dusty, offensive clothing and soaked in the tub. It felt so good to relax. A shave and clean clothes reinvigorated Joe. He returned to the hotel and headed to the cantina. Joe was ready for some fun. He ordered a tequila, then another, and another, and was enjoying the Mexican music. It was lively and upbeat. He was tapping his foot to the beat. Without warning Joe was whisked onto the dance floor to join some men doing the zapateado. Joe was stomping his feet to the rhythm of the music and keeping up quite nicely with the other men. Everyone was cheering on the Americano! Joe had so much fun. Out of breath, he stumbled back to his seat. A young senorita strolled over to sit with the sweaty, new performer. Joe’s lively performance aroused her. The young lady lusted for the new zapateado dancer. Joe felt a long-lost, familiar twitching in his pants. He willingly followed her upstairs that night. Whether it was the tequila, the enticing look of the senorita, need, or all of the above, Joe’s animal instincts kicked in. Lying naked with their bodies pressed hard against each other, Joe came to life! It was a night of hot, steamy sex that exploded in an orgasm like Joe had never experienced!

He stayed in Mexico for several more weeks enjoying the people, fiestas, and customs and culture. Joe spent some of that time at the ocean. He had fun splashing playfully in the water and jumping waves with families and their children. The little boy in Joe manifested itself and he reverted back to the days of that innocent, happy, carefree child. The adults and the children alike enjoyed Joe’s company. 

He was also fond of the solitude he found taking long walks along the beach. Breathing in sea air and hearing waves crashing on the beach, cleared Joe’s head. Serenity and peace had finally returned to Joe. He knew that life could and would be good again. 

With happiness that had eluded Joe for so long now reinfused into him, Joe decided it was time to return home. His body, mind, spirit, and soul had begun to be restored, renewed, and refreshed. He knew he would never fully heal, for the pain of grief would always be part of his life. However, Joe felt he could navigate through this grief. His fractured heart was now replaced with a warm feeling in that same heart. Thinking of all the special people whom he had loved and lost didn’t make Joe feel as sad as he had felt. This was the magic of their love. It turned his tears mostly into smiles. Joe knew he was not alone anymore. He understood that all of those brilliantly shining stars walked beside him everyday. 

There was so much more life to live, so many new adventures to experience, and perhaps, one day, a new love to meet and create a life together. Pa would certainly like having some little Cartwrights running around!

Thinking about his father, Joe couldn’t wait to go home and tell Pa of his many escapades. Well, perhaps it would be more prudent not to share all of them!

Before heading out, Joe looked up to the heavens and said, Thank you for helping me learn to live again! I love you all and will hold you in my heart forever. Until we meet again.

The End

Author’s notes:

My mother passed away on June 22, 2022 and my husband, Michael passed away October 22, 2023 after 40 years of marriage. Loss is very painful, especially when you’ve been blessed to have experienced such real and strong love. You realize you have no control over what has happened. What you do have control over is how to choose to live the rest of your life. Like Joe, I’m learning to live with grief and learning how to live again. It is a process. I’m working on taking the pain and turning it into joy for myself and for others. Besides the support and love of my family and friends, another thing that has helped me tremendously has been becoming a member of Just Joe. The camaraderie and interaction with fellow Joe lovers has been a positive force. This experience has given me the encouragement and motivation to write. Learning to Live Again is my first attempt at writing fanfiction. I hope you enjoyed reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it.

Special thanks to June Baker and Pat Grubb for sharing weekly writing tips and for their support and confidence building.

As an aside, when I was dating my husband-to-be, my knees actually did buckle the first time he kissed me on the lips! I let Sally from Justice have that same experience!

The term ‘blowing raspberries’ has been in use since at least 1890 so I took a little poetic license!

Episode Referenced: 

Bank Run written by NB Stone, Jr.

Joe Cartwright, Detective written by William F. Claxton, Michael Landon

The Storm written by Denne Bart Petitclerc

The Julia Bulette Story written by Al C. Ward 

The Truckee Strip written by Herman Groves

Justice written by Richard Wendley

Marie, My Love written by Anne Howard Bailey, Anthony LawrenceForever written by Michael Landon

Luckier Than Most

By jfclover

Chapter 1

“What’s there to worry about?   I’m only filling in for a month.  Besides, Jake Stevens is riding shotgun, and he’s the best there is.”

My father wasn’t convinced, but I needed him to believe I could do the job, and that I’d return safe and sound.  Sometimes he worried too much, and this was one of those times.  What could possibly go wrong that couldn’t go wrong if I was working at home?  Men get hurt.  Men get in trouble, but I’ve been in trouble before.  I’ve been hurt before, but I was still alive and well and able to tell my story.

“Take care, Son.”

“I will.  Don’t worry!”

When Pa dropped me at the stage depot in Virginia City, I jumped down from the seat, grabbed my assortment of luggage, and nodded at my father.  I had too many bags to ride Cooch into town, so Pa drove me in the buckboard.  He had insisted I take half of what I owned just in case.  I tried to argue but lost the battle and walked out the door with more baggage than a fancy woman would take on a cross-country trip.  I’d learned early in life to pick my battles, and this one wasn’t worth the fight. 

Pa and I didn’t always see things eye to eye, but I was due a two-week vacation, and when Mr. Owens, the station agent, asked if I’d be willing to drive his westbound stage, I couldn’t resist the adventure and said yes before talking to Pa.  That didn’t bode well, but I’d already agreed to take the position and hoped my word meant something.  When I asked my father for an extra two weeks off, that didn’t go well either although he knew how much I wanted to drive a coach and agreed to let me go.

“See you in a couple of weeks.”

“Stay safe, Son.”

“I will, Pa.”

As I turned into the station, Jake Stevens met me at the door.  “Hi, Jake.”

“Hey, Joe.  You ready for all this?”

“Ready as you are.”

“If you get me to Sacramento and back in one piece, I’ll buy the first beer.”

“And if you keep the bandits away, I’ll do the honors.”

“It’s a deal.”

I’d known Jake and his brother Josh since we were boys in school.  With bright red hair and freckles, they were tall and lanky and were the best shots in Storey County.  If Jake didn’t win a contest, Josh did.  They were highly competitive, and one was as skillful as the other when it came to loading and shooting a rifle.  I was lucky to have Jake by my side on the driver’s seat.

Mr. Owens was glad to see us on time and ready to roll.  He shook both of our hands.  That was after I’d offloaded most of my baggage in the corner of the room.  He’d been at the job as long as I can remember, and he reminded me of an old mountain man who’d turned city boy, but I doubt he’d ever spent a day in the woods with only bears and wildcats to communicate with.  I liked Mr. Owens.  He did his job well and expected his employees to do the same.

“We’ll do a good job for you,” I said.

“I hope so, Son.  You two are the finest boys I know, but don’t think this is easy money.  This is a tough job for any man who’s willing to bust his butt by driving as fast and as steady as he knows how.  Think you’re up to the job, Little Joe?”

“I sure am, and Jake is too.  You won’t have to worry about either of us filling in for a month while Ezra and Louis recuperate.  Tell them not to worry.  We’ll keep their stage intact until they’re ready to come back to work.”

Mr. Owens stepped out from behind the counter and looked us square in the eye.  “Them renegades haven’t been caught yet, Boys.”

“I know that, Sir, but Jake’s the fastest gun in the West, and as I explained to my father, there’s no need for worry.”

“Joe ain’t a bad shooter himself, Mr. Owens.  Between the two of us, we got it covered.”

The station agent landed his hands on our shoulders.  “Good luck, Boys.  That’s all I can say.”

“Thank you, Sir.”

The stage didn’t leave for another half hour, which gave me time to throw what I needed into one bag and stow the rest under Mr. Owen’s counter for safekeeping.  I’d grab them when Pa came to pick me up at the end of the month.  A few necessities were all a man needed to get by.

When it was time to climb aboard and take the reins in my hands, I was ready for the adventure of a lifetime.  Jake was too.  I could see the excitement of a brand-new mission in his eyes.  With five passengers loaded inside, and their gear thrown on top of the brightly painted red coach, we were ready to roll.  I’d ridden this road many times before, but we were still given a map that showed every way station on our route.  We would change horses every ten to fifteen miles, but we wouldn’t let the passengers out to rest every time.  Only once during the day would we stop for coffee and food.

By the time we reached the first station, Jake and I had run through all the passengers we carried.  Mr. and Mrs. Baldwin were about my father’s age and going to see their daughter in San Francisco.   Mr. Simpson was a businessman, but that’s all he had to say.   Martha Metcalf and her son, Simon, were heading west on an adventure.  We both thought she was brave to travel alone, but widows who’d lost husbands often looked for a new life away from all the brutality of war.  I had a feeling she was one of those women.

Chapter 2

It wasn’t long before we were high into the Sierras and the road became as rough as the high seas.  At least, that’s what my father would say after his many voyages as a young man.  I listened to those tales of traveling across miles and miles of ocean but didn’t really understand the concept.  Of course, I was five years old at the time, but I don’t think those stories ever left my oldest brother’s mind.   He’s a traveler now.  Sailing to different ports and seeing the sights appeals to him more than it ever did to Hoss or me.  We were satisfied to stay in one place, to work the land and enjoy the results of our labors.

When I returned home, I could tell tall tales about my monthlong travels over snowcapped mountains and through lush, green valleys, of nights spent in way stations and days spent staring at a long, continuous road that led to our destination.  

By day three, I felt at ease with the reins in my hands, and my feet propped on the boot in front of the strongbox.  We carried two thousand dollars, not a huge amount, but enough that an outlaw could live high on the hog unless he had to split the amount with his cohorts.  We’d been lucky so far.  No sign of renegade Indians and no sign of stage robbers. 

Jake and I kept our eyes peeled for any kind of disturbance.  A dust cloud that shouldn’t be in our path or noises that shouldn’t be heard in wide-open spaces would alert us to trouble.  Playing a rhythmic tune, our metal-rimmed wheels were the only sound allowed.

When we pulled into Sacramento, I was exhausted although I didn’t dare let it show.  I remember explaining conditioning to Hoss a couple of years ago, but now it was me who needed to heed my own advice.  I needed to condition myself for the long, grueling days of sitting on my butt and keeping my eyes tied to the road.  There were times I’d forget to blink, and my eyes would grow so tired and bloodshot, I wondered if I might go blind.

After we dropped our passengers off at the depot, we had a twelve-hour layover before we began the return trip.  Mr. Simpson had reached his destination, and the rest of the travelers would continue on west.  I wished everyone well, and Jake and I agreed that a cold beer and a nap were in order before we climbed aboard the same stage and headed home.

I’d told my father there wouldn’t be any trouble, but he had a hard time believing me after I told him why Jake and I were taking the place of Ezra and Louis.  They’d been caught unaware.  Road bandits wanted the strongbox and the driver and shotgun both took a bullet.  After assuring Pa that would never happen to me and Jake, that we were better shots, I still don’t think he thought my vacation sounded like a great idea.  But I was too old for him to lock me in my room and hide the key. 

I was a grown man who could make my own decisions, and the freedom of driving a coach was the most fun I’d had in a long time.  Sailing across open land and flying down mountain trails was the biggest thrill I’d ever had.  I’d be sad to let the job go at month’s end.

Before the return trip, I glanced down at the passenger list.  We only had five this time and three sacks of mail.  Three men and two women.  I didn’t take as much interest as my first run.  I’d drop two of our commuters off in Placerville and take the rest to Virginia City.  There wasn’t much point in finding out who was who.

Jake and I didn’t talk much during our journey.  We were content to sit and watch the scenery fly past.  Heck, I didn’t even need a shotgun rider on this trip.  We didn’t carry a strongbox, and it seemed a shame to waste good money on a second employee.  Most bandits were smart.  Most of them knew exactly what we carried from town to town.

We only had a four-hour layover this time, no time to visit with the family or get some much-needed sleep, but Jake and I could handle whatever was thrown our way.

When the trip was over, I winked at Jake and clapped him on the back as we crossed the street toward the saloon.  I don’t think I’ve ever swallowed so much dust in my life.”

“I know what you mean.  A little rain wouldn’t hurt.  Them roads are a dust storm in disguise.”

“Ain’t that the truth.  Let’s get a beer.  I’m buying.”

I’d swallowed so much dirt on the return trip that my throat felt ragged and sore.  I’m sure Jake’s was too, but we didn’t dwell on unpleasant things.  We’d each have a beer and wash some of the grit away before we headed back to Sacramento.  Pa would have to understand that there wasn’t enough time for a family reunion this time around

The next two runs were made in less time than I thought possible.  I assumed we’d have more time to rest between trips, but that wasn’t the case.  I needed to close my eyes.  I needed a good night’s sleep, but that would have to wait.  I didn’t realize until this week how hard a stage driver worked.  There was no time for proper sleep, and I was beginning to think that driving a bright red coach wasn’t all it was cracked up to be.

My throat hadn’t gotten any better; in fact, everything hurt.  My eyes burned, and I probably had a fever although there wasn’t much I could do but keep the stage rolling forward toward our next destination.  I didn’t say anything to Jake, but I had to squint hard to see the cut of the road.  My body began to fail me, and I couldn’t do anything about it.  By the time we dropped off our passengers in Sacramento, I could barely stand up and that’s when Jake noticed how bad off I’d become.

“You got real quiet, Little Joe, and I figured you didn’t feel good, but I didn’t know you was ready to keel over.”

“I’m fine, Jake.  I’ll be fine.  I just need some sleep.”

I’d heard about drivers that slept en route and let the team take its rein.  I hadn’t done that, and if Jake had gotten some shuteye during one of our runs, I wasn’t aware.  Surely, we’d get some time off now.  After offloading all the luggage, the two of us headed inside the depot.

“Hey, Boys. You made good time.”

“Thanks, Mr. Bates.  We aim to please.”

“That’s what I like to hear.”  The station agent had no complaints because there was nothing to complain about.  Jake and I did the job well.  We just needed a few hours off.

“Let’s see …” Bates glanced down his sheet of departures and arrivals.  “You boys have five hours before your next run.”

“Five?”

“That’s right, Mr. Cartwright.”

“Do we ever get a full night’s sleep?”

“Not till we hire more drivers.”

“It better be soon.”

Jake and I headed straight for a saloon.  I needed to clear the dust, and I needed to sleep.  It seemed ridiculous to pay for a hotel room, but if I could, I’d pay a whore for the use of her upstairs room.  Anything for a few hours of sleep would serve me well.

After a couple of warm beers, Jake leaned back in his chair and closed his eyes, and after folding my arms on the tabletop, they served as a pillow for my aching head.  When Jake shook my arm to wake me, I was so confused by my surroundings, fear rushed over me until I got my bearings and realized where we were and why we were there.

But I was quick to get back on track.  I stood from my chair but had to steady myself with my hand on the table for support.  I was dizzy and sweat trickled down the sides of my face.  I wasn’t in great shape, but I had a job to do, and I wasn’t about to shed my responsibilities just because of a few sniffles.

“We better hit the road.”

“Yeah.  It’s time.  You feel all right?”

“Good enough.  Let’s go.”

Chapter 3

A three-inch candle shone in the far corner of the room.  An old woman wearing a ratty straw hat sat in a chair whose rungs creaked on the wooden floor and woke me from a dead sleep.  A sweet scent of tobacco smelled similar to my father’s, but Pa wasn’t in the room.  This wasn’t my room or even my house.  With a corncob pipe clenched between her teeth, my host rocked back and forth as she wove a lariat with fingers plagued by rheumatism.

I stared for a long time before I got the nerve to speak.  “Hello.”

“It’s about darn time you woke.  I’s praying you wouldn’t die. I ain’t as strong as I used to be.  Didn’t want to drag you out back and have to bury you next to the other one.”

“The other one?”

“That fire-headed friend of yours.  He was dead when I found you boys lying on the side of the road.  Ain’t nobody else around, and maybe you ain’t noticed, but I ain’t a young woman.  It weren’t easy hauling you both onto the back of my wagon.” 

Jake was dead and I was alive.  What the hell happened?  Where was the stage and the people inside?  I needed a story to tell the station agent, but I couldn’t remember a thing.

“You was burnin’ up when I found you.  You’d been shot in the shoulder, but I’m afraid your friend took a bullet dead center.  That poor boy was gone before he hit the ground.”

I glanced down at my bandaged shoulder.  I hadn’t realized the extent of my injuries.  The last thing I recalled was Jake and I climbing aboard the stage for the return trip to Virginia City.  I didn’t feel well, and I was as tired as heck, but I had a job to do, and with Jake by my side, I didn’t have reason to fret.

We’d offloaded our last two passengers in Placerville and were heading home.   I tried to recall if we carried a strongbox and if memory serves, we had a boatload of cash from the Milton Mine to be dropped off at the Virginia City Bank.

“Ma’am?”

“What you need?”

“Was there a stagecoach or horses or … did you see anyone else on the road?”

“Not a soul.  You and your red-headed friend was the only ones I saw.  There weren’t no one else around.  Why you ask?  Was you on a stage?”

“Yes, Ma’am.  I was the driver.”

The old woman shook her head.  I felt like shaking mine too, but I was too tired to think about anything except how much my shoulder hurt.  Funny.  I didn’t feel an excessive amount of pain until she told me about the bullet.  Now, it hurt like hell.

Jake was twenty-four years old, too young to die for a silly job I didn’t think was that hazardous.  He was good with a gun and protected people he didn’t even know.    He was a good friend and a good man.  We’d spent hours on end drinking beer and playing cards.  We often had the same taste in women and horses.  More than once, we took off for Guthrie’s Meadow and raced our ponies.  I always won, but Jake’s mounts were always on Cooch’s tail.

The old lady brought me back to her world. “You were running a real good fever when we found you.  Don’t know how long you and that friend of yours laid out there before me and Mattie came along, but you was a mighty sick fella.”

“Mattie?”

“My granddaughter.  God knows where she is this time.  Can’t never keep that child in sight.”

No matter what age the girl was, I wasn’t dressed proper enough to be lying around the house with the woman’s granddaughter.  The old lady had seen at least half of me when she pulled the bullet from my shoulder, but a girl.  That was a whole different story.

“How much do you remember?”

“Excuse me?”  Again, my mind had slipped elsewhere, but the old lady brought me back to the present with her question.   “Nothing much.  We were heading to Virginia City and …”

“And?”

“I’m not sure.”  Had I fallen asleep?  I remember sweating, but I was so cold that I couldn’t stop shivering.  Had I crashed the coach and killed my friend, Jake?  Why couldn’t I remember?

“You was hotter’n a stovepipe, but it weren’t from the heat of the day.  Maybe you had some kind of sickness.”

“I did, but it wasn’t that bad.  I could still do my job.”

“You won’t be doing much driving for a while.  Gonna take that shoulder some time to mend.

I laid back on the gray-striped pillow and glanced around the cabin which was no larger than one of our line shacks.   The roughhewn wood lacked a coat of plaster or whitewash that would’ve brightened up the place.  There weren’t any knickknacks or piles of clutter.  Just the opposite.  The place was as sparse as I’d ever seen. 

 While the old woman sat on a wooden chair next to an eating table, she’d given me the only bed available.  Did she sleep in that chair?  Did her granddaughter?  I felt like an intruder, and I wouldn’t stay any longer than I had to, but what I needed most was a bath.

“Is there a river or a stream nearby?”

“Yeah.  Why you ask?”

I sat up and slid my legs over the side of the small bed.  Dizziness hit without warning but that was to be expected.  I’d been lying prone for a long time, and if I was going to be good for anyone, I needed to move around and get my strength back.

“I wanted to wash up some.”

“It’s down that hill behind the cabin.  Think you can make it without help?”


I smiled at the old woman.  She seemed to care more than was warranted, but I appreciated that.  I appreciated everything she’d done for me.  Repaying someone for saving my life was impossible, but I would think of something to show her how grateful I was.

“I’m sure going to try, Ma’am.”

The water I splashed on my face ran down my neck and chest and when I smoothed my hand across the back of my neck, water trickled down my back and made me shiver.  Although nothing had ever felt better, I needed to get back to the cabin and let the old woman know I was okay, but when I heard a noise on the ridge above me, I wondered if it was the old woman’s granddaughter playing in the woods that surrounded the cabin.

Not sure what I was seeing, I squinted my eyes into the sun and was shocked to see a young lady driving a wagon.  Why I thought she was only a child was stupid on my part.  She appeared to be a grown woman, but backwoods folk or not, at least I’d be a bit more presentable after my wash.

After taking a deep breath, I climbed the hill to the cabin and walked inside the dingy, dark structure.  All my life I’d been lucky to have a fine home with fine furnishings.  I often took it for granted, but when I saw how some people lived, I gave thanks for the life I was born into.

The ladies sat in the only two chairs available, and I was forced to sit back down on the bed, which was no place for a man to be when a young lady occupied the same room.  Plus, I didn’t have a shirt, and I could feel my cheeks burn at just the thought of being seen in such a state of undress.  I waited for someone to say something.  I was a guest, and it wasn’t my place to start a conversation.  I dropped my hands between my legs and stared at the dirt floor while I waited for someone else to speak.

“This is my granddaughter, Son.  Her name’s Mattie.”

I stood from the bed.  “Name’s Joe.  Pleasure to meet you, Miss Mattie.”

She dipped her head.  “Likewise, I’m sure.”

With introductions behind us, I was able to sit down and relax and not feel so much like an intruder.  I needed to be on my way, but I had no clue where I was or how far Virginia City was from the old woman’s cabin.

“I’ll be leaving in the morning.”

“Sure you’re ready, Boy?  You’re welcome to stay on till that shoulder heals a bit more.”

“I need to get back to Virginia City.  I have family there who probably think I’m dead.  I need to remedy that.”

“Oh, I didn’t know you had people.”

“Pa and my brothers.  They’ll be worried.”

“Then we’ll have to get you home.”

“I appreciate that, Ma’am.”

Mattie hadn’t moved or said a word.  With her legs crossed and her chin resting on fisted hand, she seemed bored by the whole conversation.

“Will they come looking?”

“You bet they will.”

“Then we best get you on your way.  Mattie will drive you to town in the morning.  Maybe you can catch another stage.”

“Thank you, Ma’am.  That would be great.”

Mattie had the team hitched before I crawled out of bed.  It never occurred to me she’d want to leave before sunrise.  I’d never been an early riser but seeing me up and dressed this early would have my father and brothers laughing more than was necessary.

Before I swung my legs to the floor, I smelled the old woman’s coffee brewing in a pot hanging in the fireplace.  She’d taken the bullet out of my shoulder, fed me, and housed me, for three long days.  I wasn’t sure how I’d repay her, but I’d think of something after I returned home.

After a plate of beans and bacon and two cups of very strong coffee, Mattie and I were off to town.  Though I hadn’t asked the name of the town or asked what state we were in, I put my life in the hands of the old woman’s granddaughter, but I was on my way home.  I’d take the first stage heading west and be back on the Ponderosa in no time.

Chapter 4

When three men surrounded the wagon, I raised my hands in surrender.  The last thing I needed was more trouble.  I’d already lost my friend, a brand-new stage, and a strongbox carrying five thousand dollars.  When Mattie didn’t raise her hands, I hoped the outlaws would consider that she was just my driver and not take advantage.

My gunbelt and hat didn’t follow me to the old woman’s cabin, and she never told me what happened to my shirt and jacket.  All I had left were my trousers and boots, and I looked a sight.  I’d hoped to embellish my wardrobe when I got to town, but things looked grim, maybe even hopeless.  My left arm was still in a sling.  It would be worthless to me in a fight and without a gun, I didn’t stand a chance of defending myself or the young lady driving the wagon.

“Follow me.”

That’s all that was said before Mattie turned the wagon off the main road and trailed after one of the outlaws.  With guns drawn, the other two followed behind.  I lowered my hands.  I didn’t think they’d shoot unless Mattie or I did something stupid.

If I only knew where we were.  I’d grown familiar with the route to Sacramento, but I didn’t know the surrounding area.  I’d never been off the main road except for cattle drives, and we didn’t wander around and visit the local sights with eight to nine hundred head of beeves to get to market.

The sun was high in the sky when we reached our destination, and that’s when everything fell into place.  My stagecoach was parked outside a rundown cabin that trappers probably vacated over fifty years ago, and I assumed these were the three men who took Jake and me down and with me being the only eyewitness, they weren’t about to let me ride back to Virginia City and run my mouth to the sheriff.

But the real surprise was finding out that the leader of the band of outlaws was sitting next to me on the wagon.  Once we arrived, it was Mattie who gave all the orders.  She was the head honcho, and I was her prisoner.  I’d take orders from her until she put a gun to my head and said adios.

There was a possibility that search parties were sent from both directions, but the cabin and the stage were so buried in the woods that no one would think to take the same trail we took off the main road.  That would be the miracle of all miracles, and I’d never been that lucky.

After being hauled inside the shack by one of the gunmen, he took pleasure in tying my hands behind my back and then dumping me into a wooden chair and looping the rope around the upper rungs.  I wasn’t going anywhere.  He’d done his job well.

I waited for Mattie to show up and start barking orders, but when the gunman finished with me, he headed back outside.  I’d been left alone and not privy to their conversation.  They couldn’t keep me alive.  I was the one person who could mess up their lives and send them to prison for killing Jake.

When I heard metal rims rolling away from the cabin, I couldn’t see what was happening through the one greasy window that only allowed a seated person to see the top of the pines.  It was either the wagon or the coach, but which and why?  Were they going to hide the coach in a more secure location?  We were pretty deep inside a thick forest, and I doubt anyone would find me or the coach this far off the main road.

After waiting hours for someone to return and either untie me or kill me, I had grown hungry and thirsty and with my arms pulled behind my back, my shoulder ached like crazy.  I prayed relief would come soon, but I had begun to lose hope of ever seeing Mattie or her band of outlaws again.

There were no sounds, no movement of any kind.  No horses whinnied.  No birds flitted and sang their merry tunes. I tried to make sense of it all.  Why were they staying outside the cabin?  Were they planning another holdup?  A bank robbery?  What was the next venture to gain illegal funds, and what was to become of me?

Day turned into night and night turned back into day.  No one had walked through the cabin door with rusted hinges and come to my rescue.  Still no whinnies or birdsong.  No voices, man or woman.  I’d been left alone to die in a cabin in the woods.

My father would say that the group of bandits was inhuman, that no one would leave an animal tied up without food or water much less a human being, but that’s exactly what the outlaws did to me.  My throat ached, my stomach growled, and my head lolled toward my chest.  I didn’t have the strength to sit up straight in the rickety old chair and when I shifted my weight, the chair and I toppled sideways and fell to the cabin floor.

Chapter 5

The voices surrounding me weren’t familiar, but I didn’t much care.   In whispered tones, they discussed the stage robbers and the brightly painted stage that Jake and I drove so long ago.  I didn’t add to the conversation.  I remained lying on my side on the dirt floor and wondered if anyone would notice I was there.

“I’m here.” 

I wanted to cry out.  I didn’t understand why they would leave me in such a state of discomfort. 

“Untie me from the damn chair!”

But my words weren’t heard.  My voice remained silent to everyone but me.  Didn’t they know I was dying, that I didn’t stand a chance of recovery while I was tied to an old wooden chair?  What kind of people would stand around and watch a man die?

“I’ll be leaving now.  I’ll stop back tomorrow and check on his progress.”

“Good.  I can’t thank you enough.”

“Thank you enough?  Who the hell were these folks?”

After the cabin door closed, only silence remained.  I thought someone had stayed to watch me die, but now I wasn’t sure.  I didn’t hear any movement, and I didn’t hear any voices.  I would die alone and my remains would be disposed of leaving my pa and brothers to wonder what ever happened to the youngest member of the family.  Nothing would be resolved, and they’d always question if they could’ve done more.

When I shifted onto my back and was able to stretch my arms and legs, a weird sense came over me as though I was floating or dreaming of floating.  If I hadn’t been attached to the chair, I might’ve believed all was well in the world and I was free to jump up and walk away from the cabin.  I gave myself a good laugh and then I opened my eyes.

Before I could count to three, I’d pushed myself up on a featherbed that was covered in white linens and a patchwork quilt.   The bedroom had a new coat of whitewash, and the furniture had been recently polished.  The smell of fresh-brewed coffee filled the room and made my stomach rumble with hunger.  As I swung my bare legs over the side, the door opened and my father walked inside carrying two white mugs of coffee.

“When … I mean how?”

Pa smiled as though he had pulled one over on me, which he had.  He knew a heck of a lot more than I did, but the coffee smelled good and I was grateful for small favors.

“How’d you find me?”

“I didn’t.”

“What do you mean, you didn’t?  How’d I get here?”

Pa handed me one of the mugs and pulled a chair up next to the bed.  “You’re in a private home in Placerville.”

“Placerville?”

“That’s right.  After the stage was three hours late, the sheriff headed out with a posse, but you and Jake and the stage were nowhere to be found.”

“Yeah, I know.  An old woman …”

“Old woman?”

I looked down at my hands and tried to make sense of things.  My wrists had been wrapped in white strips, but I could still feel the rough hemp and the rungs of the chair.  I could still taste the dirt I swallowed when I hit the floor.

“That was days ago.  I took a bullet.  She took care of me.”

“She did a good job, Son.  The doctor was here.  He checked the wound.  Said it looks fine.”

“Yeah, but I still don’t know how you found me.”

“The posse rode out a week later and when they spotted a fire, they followed the smoke down to the river and found the remnants of the stage you and Jake took from Sacramento.”

“Jake’s dead.”

“I’m sorry, Son.  He was a good friend.”

“Did they catch the gang?”

“No, but after riding all day, they stopped at a cabin to spend the night, and guess what they found.”

I laughed.  In spite of everything, I laughed.  “I thought I’d die alone, and you’d never know what happened.”

“It was pure luck, Joseph.  The cabin was so far off the main road, I understand why you felt that way, but luck was on our side.”

“It sure was.”

“They figure the outlaws are halfway to Mexico by now.”

“Could be.”

I propped the pillow against the headboard and dug my shoulders against its softness.  I wasn’t quite a hundred percent, but I was on my way.  My father would make sure I healed properly and then he’d take me home.

I’d miss my friend Jake, but I’d always been luckier than most.  We each took a bullet, but I survived and he didn’t.  Just as Pa said.  Luck was on my side.  I’d been patched up and found inside a cabin that was miles from nowhere.  I should’ve been buried alongside my friend.  Instead, I would go home to my family, and in time, I’d put the last few days behind me.

I wanted to believe in my father’s god, but I questioned His reasons for things I didn’t understand.  Had it been fate or providence that I would live to tell the tale of the vacation my father tried to talk me out of?  I’ll always remember the good times Jake and I had riding like the wind over the passes and down the lonely road to the next valley. 

I thought about the old woman.  She saved my life and although I wanted to do something to repay her, perhaps the best thing I could do was keep quiet about her granddaughter.  I didn’t want to be the bearer of bad news and staying away from her and the cabin might be the best thing to do.

I was young, and perhaps I was smitten with danger and adventure.  I don’t regret the decision I made.  Bad people exist in the world, and we encountered some of the worst that were ever born.  I’ll miss my friend, and I’ll remember him always, but according to Pa’s God, Jake and I will meet again someday.  I like that thought.

The End

Pat Grubb

2024 Summer Challenge

Returning Home

By Beppina

Finally, I’m home.

The house looked the same, all was quiet. I couldn’t see any horses but that doesn’t mean Pa, Hoss and Candy were out on the range. Hauling my cases up onto the veranda I looked around. The air smelt fresh and clean, just a slight odour of pine wafting across the yard. Not even the scent of Hop Sing cooking dinner.

After almost three months away I was so happy to be home. Just breathing the Ponderosa air invoked my senses. It reawakened in me why I loved this place and had no wish to leave.

My hand rested on the latch, I gave it a slight twist and pushed into the house.

“Who’s there?” Pa’s voice called out from behind his massive oak desk.

“Me, Pa. I’m home.”

Pa was at my side before I passed through to his office. His smile was the only greeting I needed.

“Welcome home, Son. We weren’t expecting you until next week.” Pa’s arms wrapped around me in a warm welcoming hug.

My bags were swiftly put to one side. I will get them sorted later. I know Hop Sing will not appreciate the dirty linen I have acquired while travelling home.

“Where is everyone?” I asked and glanced around the familiar room.

“Hoss and Candy are out fixing fences. They’ll be back for dinner. I’m sure they’ll be happy to see you back home and resuming your chores.”

“Yeah, I’m sure they will,” I replied, accompanied by a roll of my eyes.

Hop Sing came trotting into the room, his slippers flip-flopping against the wooden surface. He chattered on in Chinese telling me it was good I was home, and that he had missed me. Pa soon sent him off to prepare dinner. I had no doubt it would be a feast of my favourite foods to celebrate my return.

“So, what was Boston like? How was the wedding?”

“Great, Pa. It went well. I’ll tell you all about it over dinner.”

“And Adam?”

I restrained from snorting back my laughter. “Older brother is just fine, Pa. Older and greyer but fine. He sends his love.”

The nod of Pa’s head acknowledged his eldest son’s good health, “Give me a few minutes and I’ll be done here.” He waved across to the pile of papers covering his desk.

“I’ll go wash up and have a half-hour nap while you do if that’s ok?”

With a wave of his hand, I was dismissed, “Go, go.”

My room seemed small compared to the palatial accommodations I had been acquainted with in Boston. The window was flung wide open to let the afternoon breeze wiffle through. Sunlight streamed in, illuminating the dust motes dancing on the current of air. My bed with fresh linen and plumped pillows, was almost too inviting to resist. Keeping my boots from the covers I lay back in its soft comfortable embrace. For a moment I studied the ceiling, every crack and mark remained the same and with a contented sigh I closed my eyes and let my being relax.

A rapid pounding on my door soon woke me from my snooze. A voice that could only belong to my brother Hoss broke the tranquillity of my rest.

“Come on, sleeping beauty,” his words echoing through the door as he pushed it open, “dinner is ready.”

“Welcome home, Joe,” I greeted with a grin. “It’s good to see you.”

Big brother towered over me; a hand reached down to grip my own as he pulled me to my feet.

“Good to see you back, Short Shanks!” as I was gripped in his huge bear hug.

“Glad to be back, Hoss, umm, would you put me down now, please?”

Side by side, with one meaty arm across my shoulders, we descended the stairs. Candy and Pa stood waiting at the table eager to sit and eat.

“Welcome home, Joe.” Candy pumped my hand, “It seems like forever since you went back East.”

“Candy,” as we pulled into a hug, “good to be home.”

As I had expected, Hop Sing had rustled up some wonderful food. I will never know how he managed to do it with such little notice. It was a veritable feast and fit for a king. We all ate far more than we should and at the end, we sat back with scarcely room for dessert.

Throughout dinner, I had been feeding them little tales of my journey; some of the places I had passed through, others where I had stopped for a night or two. I had so much more to share, but I was weary. Boston was a long train and coach ride away and to be truthful after Hop Sing’s superb meal, I was shattered.

Apple cobbler was swiftly followed by coffee and Pa’s best brandy. I don’t think I’ve eaten so much since leaving Adam’s home and now I was done for.

“Checkers, Joe?” Hoss asked as he pulled the board to the low oak table.

“Not tonight, Hoss, thanks. I don’t think I can concentrate. Maybe tomorrow?”

“Candy?” It wasn’t many minutes before their game was underway. Pa settled back in his blue chair. The dancing flames caught the silver-white shine of his hair as he fixed his pipe, while the dried wood popped and crackled as the fire consumed it log by log. The room held a tangible peace about it. We were where we should be, safe within its walls and warmed at its hearth.

“Are you going to tell us more about your trip, son?”

“Not tonight, Pa. Don’t worry, you’ll hear all the news and gossip before the week is out. You’ll be regretting letting me go by then.”

“You look tired, Joe. How was the journey home?”

I chortled, “Tiring, Pa. Very tiring.”

“You can have a late morning tomorrow. I doubt Hoss or Candy will mind another day of doing your chores.”

At that comment, two heads, one fair and one dark, popped up from the checkerboard and an audible groan floated across the room.

“Okay, okay,” I capitulated, “I’ll join you tomorrow morning. Just don’t expect me too early.”

Hoss’s chuckle rumbled across, “You never get up early, Joseph, why start now?”

I was too tired to think of a smart answer, so left it at that.

I sat back on the settee. The fire cast bright lights and deep shadows about the room. The scent of pine wood smoke and Pa’s pipe tobacco mingled in the air. The faintest smell of dinner and coffee lingered long after we had finished. These were just some of the things I had missed during my time away. Pa was engrossed in his newspaper, though it seemed he had read the same page for the last ten minutes. He wore a small, contented smile. I wondered just what he was thinking.

Temptation almost got the better of me as I went to put my feet up on the low table. Pa’s eyebrows raised as he cast a warning eye in my direction. He had been waiting for my move and I had obliged him.

“Sorry, Pa.”

He returned to reading the same page of the paper, the smile wider and now obvious.

I would tell them of Boston, of Washington. Of the President and English Duke, I had met. The opulence of the wedding I had attended with Adam. Of how Adam and I had managed to stay friends for the whole of my stay. I had so much to share, but not tonight. Tonight, I wanted to enjoy the familiar closeness of my Pa, Hoss, and my friend Candy. Storytelling will wait for another day.

I was home. Everything was right in my world.

The End.

The Meaning of Forgiveness

by littlejoefan

Chapter 1

Joe’s Lament

“It’s alright, Little Joe. I don’t believe it. No-one does.”

Roy leaned back in his chair. I did not know if it was his custom to allow his prisoners to sit in his office with him by the large stove, but I was not going to question it. It was cold in that cell, despite the extra blankets he had given me. I had seen the winter worsen over the last weeks through my window, the people passing by in fur coats and hats, leather galoshes tramping through the slush and snow. Men loaded huge trees onto their buckboards, women walked with bags and brightly colored parcels under their arms. Christmas was only a week away and I was going to spend it alone in that cold cell.

“Some people might.”

“Only them as don’t know you. Little Joe, I’ve known you since you were a baby. You’re wild, yes, but you have a true heart. You would never attack a young girl like that. I would stake my very life on it.”

I shook my head. “I can’t understand it. I just can’t. Why she’d say those things. I’d never do that, ever.”

“I know. Someone beat her so badly they could have killed her. I have my suspicions.”

“You do?”

“Vic Graves.”

“He’s been long gone.”

“I reckon he came back. ‘Course, I have no proof. But he’s a nasty one, he always has been. He made her life a living hell.”

“So why? Why me?”

“I can only think she was protecting him. You’d seen her earlier that night. Weren’t you involved once?”

“Just kid’s stuff.”

Elvira. Elvira Samuels. Yes, we had seen each other once but I’d only been seventeen. It had not led anywhere because she had turned against me. She fell out of my arms into Vic’s. I’d felt sorry for her, I’d even warned her against him. But a person believes what they want to believe.

“Was she bitter against you?”

“I didn’t think so. We parted on reasonable terms, it’s not as if I hated her. Not like now.”

“Hate’ll turn you sour, Joe.”

“I do hate her! She accuses me of the worst thing she could. And now they all think I’m a monster. I’ll spend Christmas in here – ”

“I have no choice. It’s the law and the magistrate insisted on it.”

“I don’t blame you.” I tightened my lips. “I blame her.”

It was good Ray was a friend for it made my detention much more bearable than it could have been. He kept me as warm and well-fed as possible, allowing me to come out of my cell and sit with him whenever possible. My family came every day to see me. My trial was set for the third day of January so I would spend the entire season in this grim little jailhouse. The magistrate had telegraphed there should be no bail for me.

But it could have been worse.

“It’s hard without you,” Pa said to me, shaking his head. “We won’t celebrate Christmas this year.”

“Pa, you have to.”

“Why? None of us want to. Not with you in here.” He was sitting next to me on my bed and he patted my shoulder kindly. “We’ll have our Christmas when you get out.”

“Oh, Pa. I’m so sorry about all this. I don’t know why Elvira said all those things. I sit here, racking my brains. What the hell did I do to make her hate me so much?”

“Maybe it’s not hate.”

“What else could it be?”

“I don’t know. I’ve tried several times to see her but the Stauntons won’t let me get anywhere near her. I caught sight of her once or twice. She still looks badly beaten. Whoever did it really took their time over it.”

“Roy thinks it was Vic.”

“He came back?”

“Roy doesn’t know. He has no proof. I don’t know who else would do it. Still doesn’t explain why she accused me, though.”

“It started going wrong when her father left. She took it so badly. You were still with her then, weren’t you?”

“I tried to help her. I knew she was unhappy but she made it perfectly clear that I could not give her what she needed. She wanted someone to take her to bars and…other things. Someone a bit more fun. That’s what she said.”

“Oh, really?” Pa said, with a sad smile. “Unfortunately she found him, didn’t she?”

“And then her Ma died and the Stauntons took her in. I tried to warn her, I told her he was no good. I even warned him off. That was a mistake.”

“I know, I was there, remember? I thought she was going to kill you.”

My anger flared yet again. I started to pace the cell. “I tried to help her, even when we’d drifted apart. This is how she repays me. Well, never again. Nobody’ll use me like that again.”

“Little Joe, son, don’t hate.”

“Why shouldn’t I? Don’t you hate her?!”

Pa hesitated. “No, I don’t hate her. I’m very angry with her, but I don’t hate her.”

“Well, I do.”

“Hate destroys the hater much more than the hated.”

“Oh, Pa, I’ve already had this lecture from Roy. She’s got me stuck in this cell. Everyone thinks I’m a monster – ”

No-one thinks that.”

“The magistrate does.”

“The magistrate doesn’t know you. He’s just following the law.”

“And she’ll keep on lying. She’ll lie me straight into the pen. It wouldn’t be so bad if I just knew why she was doing it!”

Pa’s face twisted. “I intend to find out.”

*

Chapter 2

Ben’s Resolution

It had hurt me to see my son in that cell. I knew Roy was treating him well, I had no concerns for his physical welfare. But Joe was only nineteen. He was still a kid and I did not like what this was doing to his mind. He had always been the pluckiest, most rascally youngster I had ever known, but his heart was pure gold. To see him pacing that tiny room, his face contorted with anger and hatred was like a knife in my chest.

It would be his first Christmas away from home. We had not decorated this year – would not. For what was the point if our youngest was not with us? As much as Hoss would mumble and blush, and Adam snipe in his most sardonic way, I knew they felt the same. There was an aching emptiness hanging over the Ponderosa. Even Hop Sing had stopped threatening to go back to China. He neither scolded nor lost his temper any more. In fact he had become very pleasant and dutiful. It was getting too hard to bear.

I would see Miss Elvira Samuels. Whether she wanted to or not, she owed us at least an explanation. An explanation as to why she was ripping my family apart in this holy season. As to why she could accuse my warm-hearted son of the worst crime she could think of.

I did not know how I could get to talk to her. I had tried twice but been stopped by Grace Staunton. The Stauntons were cousins of her late mother and lived on a dirt-poor farm just beyond the boundary to the Ponderosa on the way to Virginia City. They were not good folks and I suspected they treated Elvira badly. But they were proud and did not take well to outside interference.

Five days before Christmas I got my chance. I was told by Roy Coffee first the previous day. It was as he had suspected, Vic Graves was back in town.

“Like a bad penny,” the old lawman growled. “I thought we had seen the back of him.”

Joe did not take well to the news. “It’ll mean more trouble. He’ll encourage her.”

“Not if I have anything to do with it,” I replied grimly.

“Pa, what can you do? Face it, I’ll be stuck here over Christmas. I’ve accepted it.”

I stayed as long as I could with my son and it was late in the afternoon as I made to leave for home. Adam and Hoss were to see him the following day. As I rode I saw the two figures by the stream, dismounted and approached them. I stood just within the treeline, watching, within earshot. She was in tears, moaning, and almost pleading with her man.

“I can’t stay there any longer, I can’t. I won’t. You don’t know what it’s like. Staunton has an interest in me, the old lady blames me. I thought my own Ma was bad. Pa was my only comfort, but when he left…” She sobbed as if her heart would break.

“Anyway, how do I know it’s mine? Who knows how many men you’ve been with?”

She tried to strike him and he shook her like a terrier shakes a rat.

“You know it’s yours! I stuck up for you, didn’t I? I never told, I even blamed poor Joe Cartwright, who’s a better man than you’ll ever be! When she finds out she’ll throw me out! Don’t you care?”

He pushed her away. “It’s your problem. You ain’t gonna tie me down.”

“Vic, I’m begging you!”

“Take your hands off me. I’m warning you – ”

“Oh, yes! You warn me, you warn me all the time! Here – ” She pointed to the bruises which still decorated her face. “I’ve still got the marks of your warnings!”

“You keep on. You forget I’m the boss – ”

“Oh, no, I never forget! You don’t let me! You’d even batter a pregnant woman – ”

“Listen, girl, you knew the score. It was good while it lasted then you try to trap me. I’m not gonna be tied down to this blasted place for the rest of my life!”

“And what about me!” she shrieked. “I’m carrying your child! What shall I do? Where shall I go?”

“Forget it, Elvira. You’re on your own.”

He turned his back and went to go back to his horse. In a frenzy of passion she beat his shoulders and back and he knocked her to the ground. It was too much. I was angry with the girl but I could not let this pass. I bellowed and ran towards them. He had already mounted and she was sobbing on the grass, listening to the thundering hooves as he rode away.

I raised her to her feet. “Come on, let me help you.”

“Mr Cartwright!” Her lip was bleeding.

“You have some explaining to do. But first we have to get you cleaned up. Where’s your horse?”

“Over there. Oh, please leave me alone. Please!”

“I heard.”

“What?”

“All of it. Or enough. How you blamed my son. How you’re…you’re going to have a baby.”

She stared at me, reddening with shame beneath her bruises. “Leave me, Mr Cartwright. You have less reason to care than anyone.”

“Why did you accuse Little Joe?” I watched her lower her head. “Don’t you realize the harm you’ve done?”

“I couldn’t…Mr Cartwright, I’m having Vic’s child. The Stauntons will throw me from the door. Who else would look after me? I…I couldn’t think what else to do.”

“So you blame an innocent boy? So you could be with a brute?” She was shaking so hard I took off my coat and covered her shoulders. “It’s freezing, come on.”

“I have nowhere to go, Mr Cartwright.”

“First you will come with me. You’re going to retract your charge against my son.”

“But I can’t – !”

“What good will it do now? By tomorrow Vic will be long gone. You know he’s not staying. What good will it do to keep up your lie? What has Joe ever done to you? You said yourself he’s twice the man Vic is.”

It was cold, the light was turning, but I was determined my boy would not stay a moment longer in jail than necessary. I did not know if Roy would be able to release him immediately, he would have to file a report and take a deposition from Elvira. She would be lucky if she was not charged herself. I could not help but feel sorry for her as she wept and shook against my shoulder. Joe had loved her once.

*

Chapter 3

Forgiveness

My head reeled. Finally! I was free! On Christmas Eve I was following my father and my brothers home. Home. To the Ponderosa. I felt the vastness of the open space after the confinement of the jailhouse like a godsend. A Christmas miracle. The wind whipped my hair as we cantered and I laughed when it started to snow.

Hoss and Adam told me of the frantic preparations at the ranch. The rush to decorate, Hop Sing’s return to his normal cheerful self as he cooked, swore and banged about in the kitchen. There was only one thing to darken my soul.

Her. That damn girl. I could not believe she was staying at the house after what she had done. Pa had explained that her fears had been right, the Stauntons had thrown her out on her ear, and he could think of nowhere else she could go so soon before Christmas.

“Let her look to herself.”

“Joe! She’s going to have a baby!”

I was stunned. “What?”

“Vic’s baby.”

“And where is he?”

“He left as soon as he found out.”

I was silent. “But, Pa, after what she did…”

“What would you have me do, Joe? What would you do? It’s winter, she has no home. No parents. Would you leave her out in the snow? In her condition?”

I eventually shook my head. “No.”

He put his arms around me. “You wouldn’t do it to a dog. Or any animal.”

A dog would not have accused me of the worst thing he could think of.

“Alright. I’ll be civil to her, but that’s all.”

“That’s all I ask. Although…” He trailed off.

“Although what?” I asked sharply. I had a notion of what he was going to say next.

“Joe, it’s Christmas. Perhaps you could find it in your heart to forgive her. If only a little.”

“Do you forgive her?”

“I don’t know,” he answered, shaking his head. “I don’t know if I can. I shall try.” He laughed. “Or at least I shall try to try. All I know is I could not leave a pregnant, homeless girl out in the cold over Christmas.”

And so I was going home.

The place was bright and cheerful as we went in. The fire was roaring and the room was festooned with holly, ivy and mistletoe. I could smell warm and wonderful aromas from the kitchen as Hop Sing prepared for the morrow. My brothers were putting up the horses and Pa and I took off our coats and roasted in front of the fire for a while.

“Where is she?”

“In her room. She’s spent most of her time up there although I’ve tried to encourage her to come down. I think she’s ashamed. I know she weeps.”

“It must be cold up there,” I said grudgingly.

“Yes. It must be.”

I sighed. I knew what he wanted. My heart was split. I had cared for her once, but my anger had been so great over the last few weeks. Later that afternoon I felt their eyes as they watched me, Pa, Adam and Hoss. Damn them.

I volunteered to fetch her for supper. I heard her sobbing on the landing. I knocked and entered and she quickly rose as I entered.

“Little Joe!”

My nickname did not usually bother me but it irked me when she used it. I no longer considered her my friend.

“Elvira.”

She was broken. Her face was pale and gaunt and still bearing signs of Vic’s ill use. Her eyes were red and puffy from her tears. She stood against the wall, her hands at her throat and I saw fear in her eyes. That annoyed me too.

“I’m sorry, Joe. I know you can’t forgive me. I didn’t know what to do. You see, I’m…I’m going to have a baby.”

“I know,” I said softly.

“I’m sorry to be here. Your father insisted. I’ll keep out of your way, I promise. Even tomorrow. It’s Christmas Day, I know, but…but I don’t deserve anything else. I’ll keep to myself.”

“There’s no need for that. You shouldn’t be shivering up here on your own.”

“That’s good of you, Little Joe. But then you always were good.” She paused, staring at me in entreaty. “You’re worth ten of him.”

“He beat you when he knew you were expecting?”

“I loved him. I thought he loved me. Maybe I can’t be loved. After what I did…Vic didn’t love me. Ma didn’t. The Stauntons…Even Pa left. And you…you loved me once.”

“Yes. Once.”

“And you hate me now. I don’t blame you. I’d feel the same way.”

I sighed, feeling the stirring of pity for her. “I don’t hate you, Elvira.”

“Don’t you? I would. In fact I do. Hate myself, that is.”

“Maybe one day you’ll be able to forgive yourself.”

*

Christmas Day was quiet, but it was a happy one. As we celebrated the auspicious birth I tried – I really tried. I was still angry, but I knew I would forgive her. I was a long way short, but I would try to follow the example of someone who forgave far worse nearly nineteen hundred years ago…

The End

Author’s Notes:
The story was inspired by The Wormwood Cup, which showed Joe’s capacity to forgive, even those who had tried to kill him.